She’s the poster child for estate tax repeal, but her sad family saga doesn’t add up

Rep. Kristi Noem, R-S.D.

Republican Rep. Kristi Noem of South Dakota is one of the negotiators trying to reconcile the House and Senate tax bills. No doubt House Speaker Paul Ryan views her as a strong voice for estate tax repeal, because of her personal story of how her farming family struggled to pay the tax.

The House bill would abolish the estate tax, a levy on the intergenerational transfer of immense wealth. The Senate version retains the tax but doubles the wealth exempted from the tax, to $22 million for a family.

Congressional Republicans and their backers have painted the estate tax as a major burden on the nation’s ranchers and farmers. Yet it’s the heirs of multimillionaires and billionaires who actually pay it.

More:Trump and GOP promised America an anti-Washington party. Where is it?

More:There’s too much tax increasing in Republican tax cut plan.

Noem perpetuates the “estate tax hurts farmers” argument using her life experience. The story she tells, however, does not line up with some very basic tenets of the tax code. Now, 23 years later, it is high time to get the facts. It’s also an important time to understand just who is subject to the estate tax and what its repeal really means.

Explore more:  'Signers in Blood' shares same goal as al-Qaeda

On April 16, 2015, Noem stepped onto the floor of the House and described how her father was killed on March 10, 1994 in a tragic accident on their family farm. Noem, who was a 21-year old student at the time, recounted:.

It wasn’t very long after he was killed that we got a bill in the mail from the IRS that said we owed them money because we had a tragedy that happened to our family … We could either sell land that had been in our family for generations or we could take out a loan. So I choose to take out a loan but it took us 10 years to pay off that loan to pay the federal government those death taxes. It is one of the main reasons I got involved in government and politics was because I didn’t understand how bureaucrats and politicians in Washington DC could make a law that says when a tragedy hits a family they somehow are owed something from that family business.

There are several important questions raised by Noem’s account. First, the estate tax has had a 100% marital deduction since 1982. In other words, upon the death of Noem’s father, all the family assets could have flowed to her mother without being subject to the estate tax. Noem’s parents were married and her mother, Corinne Arnold, is still alive today.

“It’s hard to believe the estate of a farmer who died in 1994 and was survived by his spouse was subject to tax,” said Robert Lord, a Phoenix tax attorney with an expertise in estate tax law. “It easily could have been deferred. That would have been a no-brainer.”.

Explore more:  MI hospital worker sues, says he was tapped to play active shooter in unannounced drill

In the event that the Arnold family did owe taxes, the IRS had flexible installment plan at an interest rate lower than any lender. There would have been no need to get a loan from a third-party. But this doesn’t answer the fundamental question: Why did they pay any tax?

“It’s very unclear they would have been subject to the estate tax given the law at the time,” said Lord. “But if she did pay a big estate tax bill. She should elaborate on the unusual circumstances.”.

The number of farmers subject to the estate tax has been dramatically reduced as have the total number of estates. South Dakota is the state with the fewest taxable estates in the entire country, roughly 15 a year.

In her speeches attacking government overreach, Noem leaves out another important fact. Between 1995 and 2016, her family-owned Racota Valley Ranch in Hazel, S.D. Cashed $3,704,415 million in government farm subsidies. In 2012 alone, they accepted $232,707 in subsidies.

More:Republicans face 2017 deadline to brag about their tax plan.

POLICING THE USA: A look at race, justice, media.

Given that Kristi Noem is now the national face for estate tax repeal, it would be reasonable to ask these simple questions:.

Why did your family not use the spousal exemption to pass along assets to your mother and avoid any estate taxes?

Did you actually get a bill from the IRS? Please show evidence of this bill and the date (redacting out any personal financial information).

Explore more:  England comes from behind to beat Colombia, advance to World Cup semifinals

Did you actually get a loan from a third party to pay the taxes and from where?

If the government is so tyrannical, why has your family cashed over $3.7 million in taxpayer funded farm subsidy checks since 1995?

Losing one’s father and family breadwinner is a traumatic event. But 23 years later, this story is still being used to justify the elimination of a tax that is now exclusively paid by multimillionaires and billionaires. It applies to about 5,000 estates out of some 2.6 million deaths a year. That’s two out of 1,000.

Doubling the estate tax exemption will cost an estimated $83 billion over the next decade while abolishing the estate tax will cost over $269 billion over the same period.

Before she leads the GOP crusade to abolish the estate tax, Kristi Noem has some accounting of her own to do.

Chuck Collins is director of the Program on Inequality at Institute for Policy Studies and co-editor of Inequality.Org and author ofBorn on Third Base: A One Percenter Makes the Case for Tackling Inequality, Bringing Wealth Home, and Committing to the Common Good. Follow him on Twitter: @chuck99to1.

Related Posts

Terms & Conditions

Maybe you are interested Photo tour: The magical island of Santorini, Greece Head of Japan’s sumo association apologizes after female medics ordered out of ring Kid Line…

Return & Refund Policy

Maybe you are interested Friday’s forecast: Southern storms, western snow Cowboys center Travis Frederick has neurological disorder With Messi at his best, Barcelona had no title rival…

Cookies Policy

Maybe you are interested 7v7 soccer positions Surging Brewers clinch playoff berth with 9-2 win over Reds 2024 sec football schedule Alabama A&M beats Mississippi Valley State…


Maybe you are interested Coronavirus updates: New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo rips White House ‘surrender’; 45 states report rise in weekly cases; US deaths top 225K soccer…

Privacy Policy

Maybe you are interested how to watch michigan football Two weeks later, A’s prospect Jesus Luzardo finally on field Turkish cave rescue underway: International teams prep to…


Maybe you are interested Ian Ziering remembers his ‘Beverly Hills, 90210’ dad Jed Allan in touching post Richard Simmons sets record straight: ‘I’m not transitioning’ ‘Signers in…