Paris slaughter can’t silence free expression: Our view

Memorial protest in Paris on Wednesday night.

Cartoonists are not ordinarily people you’d think of as threatening. Their most dangerous weapon is rapier wit, artistically aimed to provoke thought. But for the thin-skinned, the intolerant and the arrogant, mockery stings more than an acid bath.

So on Wednesday, in an act of primitive brutality, Islamist radicals angered by the work of four cartoonists simply murdered them, along with other journalists and bystanders at the satirical Paris weekly Charlie Hebdo.

The satirists might be unlikely heroes, but they are heroes nevertheless — martyrs to that most fundamental of Western values, the right to free expression, which they chose to exercise despite threats and a firebombing just three years ago that might have muted others.

Their form of speech was not the easiest to defend. Like other satirical publications, Charlie Hebdo aims to be offensive, and it succeeds. The newspaper regularly mocks politicians and religious leaders of all types, including Catholics and Jews. Muslim radicals have been a recurring target.

A decade ago, Charlie republished a collection of Danish cartoons depicting the prophet Mohammed that had set off worldwide riots. Muslims sued for blasphemy and lost.

Explore more:  Prince Harry, during royal tour of Africa, recreates unforgettable Princess Diana moment

In 2011, a cover renamed the magazine Charia Hebdo, a play on sharia, or Islamic law, and said the issue was edited by Mohammed. The firebombing followed.

Gallery: The daring covers of Charlie Hebdo.

Undeterred, Charlie Hebdo set off an uproar again in 2012. After a U.S.-Produced anti-Islam film ignited a fresh round of rioting, the weekly rejected government pleas not to fan the flames and published a cartoon depicting Mohammed naked. Other cartoons, articles and editorials ridiculing Islamic extremism appeared along the way, drawing threats, a cyberattack and ultimately Wednesday’s massacre.

Looking at that history, one might be tempted to say the tabloid acted like a man who pokes a bear with a stick; it’s no surprise that the bear clawed back. But that would miss the point. So, too, would it be a mistake to focus on the crudeness of the newspaper’s humor or its apparent indifference to the consequences of its actions.

Instead, the issue is free speech, which inevitably involves tolerance of offensive speech. The unacceptable alternative is to have speech judged by government censors.

Muslim extremists reject this concept of free expression. They say that nothing is more important to Islam than revering its founder and protecting him from insults, and that Western societies must bend to Allah’s dictates. You can read their reasoning in the opposing view from a radical London cleric.

He and his brethren argue that they seek only tolerance and respect, which all religions deserve, but they demand fealty that is fundamentally incompatible with Western concepts of freedom. Governments have no business enforcing their beliefs, or those of anyone else.

Explore more:  Wolff scores late to help Atlanta United grab 1-1 draw with Orlando City

That’s a big part of what Charlie Hebdo’s satirists were trying to say. The idea that they should die for saying it is an outrage that should be repudiated by every civilized person, Muslim or not.

USA TODAY’s editorial opinions are decided by its Editorial Board, separate from the news staff. Most editorials are coupled with an opposing view — a unique USA TODAY feature.

To read more editorials, go to the Opinion front page or sign up for the daily Opinion e-mail newsletter.

ufc fight night obstawianie

psg al nassr wynik

tour de france zakłady

us monastir x al-nassr

lajfy piłka

bet victor fury

livesport 365

Related Posts

Terms & Conditions

Maybe you are interested Packers DT Letroy Guion gets 4-game suspension As ‘viral’ as it gets: Trump photo goes global First confirmed US case of the omicron…

Return & Refund Policy

Maybe you are interested Ask Matt: Can J.C. Penney remain relevant? Jewish campus groups optimistic despite statistics Jordan: Career scoring leader Walker is epitome of a Hornet…

Cookies Policy

Maybe you are interested St. Francis wins Battle of Brooklyn 64-49 over LIU-Brooklyn wiaa soccer playoffs WBC provides playoff atmosphere Miami’s Stanton craves Report: Former NBA star…


Maybe you are interested Wyoming Rep. Liz Cheney: Ukraine phone call is ‘starting to seem like a political set up’ against Donald Trump Branson duck boat salvage,…

Privacy Policy

Maybe you are interested best defense for fantasy football 2023 Grizzlies beat Kings 97-85 for 5th straight win Palestinians call off peace talks after clash city soccer…


Maybe you are interested Is it safe to go to the pool over Memorial Day during COVID-19? Can grandkids visit? Your reopening questions, answered Youngster tenderly helps…